Hackers and malware are routine threats for most healthcare organizations, but this year saw criminals add a devastating tool to their arsenal: ransomware.
Although the dramatic increase in ransomware attacks against healthcare organizations is largely a recent phenomenon, ransomware itself is not new. According to the FBI, it's been around for several years, but the agency began to see an uptick in ransomware attacks in 2015, particularly against organizations. Early this year, the Department of Defense specifically warned healthcare organizations that they are a top target for ransomware. As ransomware continued to grab headlines and lawmakers called for official action, HHS released ransomware response and prevention guidance for healthcare organizations (www.aha.org/content/16/160620cybersecransomware.pdf).
State and federal lawmakers took notice as well. At a March 22 joint hearing of the House of Representatives subcommittees on Information Technology and Health Care, Benefits, and Administrative Rules, some lawmakers suggested HIPAA should be modified to specifically require covered entities and business associates to report ransomware attacks.
Security officers must act now to protect their organizations, and in turn, organizations must be prepared to invest in security and carefully follow related policies. The price for failing to do so could be high.
Q: I am a certified case manager working in an acute care hospital. As part of our job requirements, when working in the emergency room (ER), we are asked to problem solve throughout the day. We often get requests for information on patients seen in the ER who have since been discharged.
Editor's note: This is part one of a series about medical identity theft. Look for part two in an upcoming issue of BOH.
Privacy and security officers are sitting on a hoard of valuable data: medical identity information. Social Security numbers. Medicare, Medicaid, and other insurer numbers. Credit card and bank account information. This data can fetch a high price on the black market, and medical identity theft costs patients, providers, and insurers millions of dollars a year. The lure of medical identity information makes healthcare organizations an appealing target for criminals, from large operations launching sophisticated hacking schemes to smaller groups running tried and true fraud scams.
A 2015 study conducted by the Ponemon Institute and sponsored by the Medical Identity Fraud Alliance (MIFA), the Fifth Annual Study on Medical Identity Theft, found that medical identity fraud nearly doubled between 2010 and 2014. More than 2.3 million adults were victims of medical identity theft and fraud in 2014 alone. The average cost per victim was $13,500 and the combined out-of-pocket cost was approximately $20 billion. But the financial impact is only the tip of the iceberg. Medical identity theft can result in physical harm to a patient if the medical record is altered to include another person's information such as allergies, disease status, or blood type.
Healthcare organizations often absorb some of the costs, and if the stolen PHI was used to commit Medicare or Medicaid fraud, they could be investigated by the OIG.
The stakes are high but by raising awareness and championing education and robust security programs, privacy and security officers can help their organizations stay one step ahead of criminals.
Information systems activity review is a fancy way of saying you need to monitor your network and your applications including who is looking at and manipulating your patient information. That can be an expensive, or even almost impossible, proposition when it comes to regular monitoring of access to patient information stored in electronic health records (EHR). Two of the well-known automated audit logging tools on the market, FairWarning and Iatric, are well outside the budget for small- to medium-sized covered entities (CE). The manual option, checking audit logs by hand, is slow and ineffective.
As Phase 2 of the HIPAA audit program begins, covered entities (CE) and business associates (BA) will be watching their email for an audit letter from OCR. Of those chosen for audit, most will be selected for a desk audit. They'll have 10 days after receipt of the email to gather requested documents for OCR's auditors.
But how will CEs and BAs know they are collecting the right information? A careful reading of the updated Phase 2 audit protocol (www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/audit/protocol/index.html) will help guide CEs and BAs. But if the protocol isn't read carefully, and in full, important documents could easily be left out, leading to inaccurate audit reports and even a visit from OCR's investigators.
The Phase 2 audit protocol expands the Phase 1 compliance areas to reflect changes made by the 2013 HIPAA omnibus final rule. The updated audit protocol also includes information for BAs, which were not audited during Phase 1 but will be in the current round of audits. The protocol contains a description of the audit areas, general instructions and definitions, and a keyword-searchable table.
Phase 2 audits will be conducted in three rounds. The first two rounds will consist of desk audits of specific audit targets, while the third round will be comprehensive audits. Round one audits will target CEs and round two audits will target BAs.
Q: Is it permissible to take pictures of patients for identification purposes as a part of the registration process? Do the patients need to sign a consent form before their picture can be taken?
A: It is permissible to take pictures of patients for identification purposes if the patient agrees to it. Since the Privacy Rule considers full-face photographs to be a patient identifier, it is a good practice to get the patient's written consent to take a photograph and file it with the patient's electronic record. The patient should be allowed to opt out of the photograph if he or she chooses.
Editor's note
Brandt is a healthcare consultant specializing in healthcare regulatory compliance and operations improvement. She is also an advisory board member for BOH. This information does not constitute legal advice. Consult legal counsel for answers to specific privacy and security questions. Opinions expressed are those of the author and do not represent HCPro or ACDIS. Email your HIPAA questions to Associate Editor Nicole Votta at nvotta@hcpro.com.
